The Secret Eleventh Egg – Mysterious Mission Discussion Thread
Alright, I know the program says there are 10 eggs in MLB The Show 25, but there’s something weird happening after you finish them all. A few people I’ve talked to—including myself—have noticed a hidden reward or mission trigger after the last egg is colleBuy mlb 25 stubscted. Let’s talk about it.
After I claimed Egg #10, I went back into Ranked with my new Egg Hunt reward players just to mess around. During that game, I stole a base, hit a triple, and ended up playing nine innings due to extras. I didn’t think much of it, but when I returned to the Program screen, I got a strange animation and a reward pop-up: “You cracked the mystery.” It gave me bonus XP and a hidden Boss Pack.
It might not be an actual eleventh egg, but it’s definitely something hidden.
What I’ve gathered so far:
It seems like this mystery trigger requires using multiple Egg Hunt reward players in a single game.
Doing multiple egg-like tasks in one match (e.g., steal, triple, base hit with Boggs) might unlock it.
It appears most often in online games, especially Ranked and Events.
Some others are saying they saw the bonus trigger when playing a Mini Seasons game with a full Egg Hunt-themed squad. Others think it’s tied to equipping gear or completing secondary objectives tied to Easter themes (like using the Jelly Bean items or Egg Hunt equipment).
It might just be a hidden XP dump or a one-time bonus, but it definitely caught me off guard in a good way.
Has anyone else seen this or figured out the exact criteria? Let’s pool some knowledge. If it’s consistent, it might be worth it to run a team fully made up of Egg Hunt players in different modes and see what shakes loose.